Below you will find the rubric you as a class came up with for the citizenship ratings for this class.

Please remember the thing being judged is CITZENSHIP (specifically citizenship as defined below by the members of this class) NOT participation. You will note that the list below requires much more than what we usually think of as "class participation."

A 4.0 citizen of this class:

• Is professional and respectful.
• Is original.
• Communicates well.
• Interrupts judiciously.
• Lets others' ideas be fully stated before speaking.
• Does not monopolize the conversation.
• Is concise.
• Comes to class prepared.
• Is courteous.
• Hears other people's opinions, and doesn't just hold her/his own ground or issues.
• Is open-minded.
• Is an active member of the class.
• Sticks to the arguments and doesn't make personal attacks.

• exhibits most of the above, but exhibits some important problem spots.

• exhibits some of the 4.0 behaviors but also a fair number of the 0.0 behaviors.

• exhibits behaviors much closer to the 0.0 type than the 4.0 type.

• is rude and obnoxious.
• Is late a lot without just cause.
• Is undependable in groups.

• Is unprofessional and disrespectful.
• Is unoriginal.
• Communicates poorly or not at all.
• Interrupts.
• Fails to let others' ideas be fully stated before speaking.
• Monopolizes the conversation.
• Comes to class unprepared.
• Fails to hear other people's opinions, and just holds her/his own ground or issues.
• Is close-minded.
• Is not an active member of the class.
• Make personal attacks.